Rightsy — Protect your rights: IP search and flat-fee legal services

Search trademarks

LEGO Juris A/S v. Above.com Domain Privacy / Shu Lin

WIPO Case No. D2013-0896

Outcome
Transfer
Domain names
legodcuniverse.com
Complainant
LEGO Juris A/S (Denmark)
Complainant's counsel
Melbourne IT Digital Brand Services AB
Respondent
Above.com Domain Privacy / Shu Lin (China)
Panelist
Ana María Pacón
Registrar
Above.com, Inc.
Decided
23 Jul 2013
Response
The respondent did not reply
Language
English

Source: WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Center. Official copy: https://www.wipo.int/amc/en/domains/decisions/text/2013/d2013-0896.html

WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Center

ADMINISTRATIVE PANEL DECISION

LEGO Juris A/S v. Above.com Domain Privacy / Shu Lin

Case No. D2013-0896

1. The Parties

The Complainant is LEGO Juris A/S of Billund, Denmark, represented by Melbourne IT Digital Brand Services AB, Sweden.

The Respondent is Above.com Domain Privacy of Beaumaris, Victoria, Australia / Shu Lin of Zhongshan District, Dalian, China.

2. The Domain Name and Registrar

The disputed domain name <legodcuniverse.com> is registered with Above.com, Inc. (the “Registrar”).

3. Procedural History

The Complaint was filed with the WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Center (the “Center”) on May 22, 2013. On May 22, 2013, the Center transmitted by email to the Registrar a request for registrar verification in connection with the disputed domain name. On May 23, 2013, the Registrar transmitted by email to the Center its verification response disclosing registrant and contact information for the disputed domain name which differed from the named Respondent and contact information in the Complaint. The Center sent an email communication to the Complainant on May 28, 2013, providing the registrant and contact information disclosed by the Registrar, and inviting the Complainant to submit an amendment to the Complaint. The Complainant filed an amendment to the Complaint on May 28, 2013.

The Center verified that the Complaint together with the amendment to the Complaint satisfied the formal requirements of the Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (the “Policy” or “UDRP”), the Rules for Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (the “Rules”), and the WIPO Supplemental Rules for Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (the “Supplemental Rules”).

In accordance with the Rules, paragraphs 2(a) and 4(a), the Center formally notified the Respondent of the Complaint, and the proceedings commenced on May 28, 2013. In accordance with the Rules, paragraph 5(a), the due date for Response was June 17, 2013. The Respondent did not submit any response. Accordingly, the Center notified the Respondent’s default on June 19, 2013.

The Center appointed Ana María Pacón as the sole panelist in this matter on July 9, 2013. The Panel finds that it was properly constituted. The Panel has submitted the Statement of Acceptance and Declaration of Impartiality and Independence, as required by the Center to ensure compliance with the Rules, paragraph 7.

The language of the proceeding is English, as per paragraph 11(a) of the Rules.

4. Factual Background

The Complainant is a Danish company founded in 1953. It is a market leader in construction toys with operation in more than 130 countries, including China. The LEGO Group has in the last years expanded its activities to computer hardware and software, books, videos and computer controlled robotic construction sets.

The Complainant has several trademark registrations for the trademark LEGO. As an example, reference is made to European Union registration CTM No. 39800, to the United States “US” registrations No. 2,245,652 and 1,018,875, and to the Chinese registration No. 75,682. These trademarks have been also incorporated in domain name registrations in the “.com”, “.info”, “.org” and “.net” TLDs. The Complainant is the owner of more than 2,400 domain names.

According to a printout of the WhoIs database the disputed domain name was registered on March 3, 2013.

5. Parties’ Contentions

A. Complainant

The Complainant contends the following:

- The trademark LEGO is among the best–known trademarks of the world. In fact, in a list of the official 500 top Super brands for 2009/2010 LEGO was number 8.

- The disputed domain name comprises the word “lego”, which is identical to the registered trademark LEGO. The addition of the terms “dc” and “universe” are not relevant. In addition, the Complainant has a product line called LEGO DC Universe. So, the suffixes strengthen the impression that the disputed domain name is owned or in some way connected to the Complainant.

- The Respondent doesn’t have any registered trademarks or trade names corresponding to the disputed domain name. The Complainant has also not found anything that would suggest that the Respondent has been using LEGO in any other way. Consequently, the Respondent may not claim any rights established by common usage.

- No license or authorization of any other kind has been given by the Complainant to the Respondent to use its trademark.

- The mere registration of a domain name does not give the owner a right or a legitimate interest in respect of a domain name.

- It is unlikely that the Respondent would not have known of the Complainant’s rights in the trademark LEGO at the time of the registration of the disputed domain name. This is a proof that the Respondent’s interests are not legitimate.

- The Respondent is not actually using the disputed domain name to offer goods or services. Instead of that the Respondent is using its domain name to generate traffic in site with sponsored links. By doing this, the Respondent is misleading Internet users to commercial web sites.

- The Respondent is trying to sponge off the Complainant’s well-known trademark.

- The Complainant tried to contact the Respondent on April 5,16 and 22, 2013, through a cease and desist letter. The Complainant requested a voluntary transfer of the disputed domain name and offered compensation for the expenses of registration and transfer fees. According to many UDRP cases the failure of a Respondent to response to a cease and desist letter, has been considered relevant in a finding of bad faith.

- The Respondent is using the disputed domain name to attract visitors to his own web site by creating a likelihood of confusion with the Complainant’s trademark.

B. Respondent

The Respondent did not reply to the Complainant’s contentions.

6. Discussion and Findings

According to paragraph 15(a) of the Rules, the Panel shall decide a Complaint in accordance with the Policy, the Rules and any rules and principles of law that it deems applicable.

Paragraph 4(a) of the Policy directs that the Complainant must prove each of the following:

(i) the domain name registered by the Respondent is identical or confusingly similar to a trademark or service mark in which the Complainant has rights; and

(ii) the Respondent has no rights or legitimate interests in respect of the domain name; and

(iii) the domain name has been registered and is being used in bad faith.

A. Identical or Confusingly Similar

A Complainant must establish two elements under paragraph 4(a)(i) of the Policy: i) the Complainant has rights in a trademark or a service mark, and ii) the disputed domain name is identical or confusingly similar to the mark in which the Complainant has rights.

The Complainant has provided sufficient evidence of its rights in the trademark LEGO in several countries worldwide.

The relevant trademark would generally need to be recognizable as such within the domain name, with the addition of common terms typically being regarded as insufficient to present threshold Internet user confusion. This will particularly be the case where the trademark is inherently distinctive and widely-known. (Lilly ICOS LLC v. John Hopking/Neo net Ltd., WIPO Case No. D2005-0694).

In the present case, the disputed domain name <legodcuniverse.com> contains the trademark LEGO in its entirety. The addition of the terms “dc” and “universe” are insufficient to distinguish the Complainant’s trademark from the disputed domain name. Moreover, these terms correspond with a product line “LEGO DC Universe” offered by the Complainant. Internet users will understand the addition of the suffixes to the Complainant’s trademark in the sense that Respondent’s website is specific for the Complainant’s product line LEGO DC Universe. So Internet users would likely be confused into thinking that it is owned or associated with the Complainant.

The addition of the generic top level domain name “.com” may be disregarded for the purpose of this comparison. It is well established in previous UDRP cases that the added of top-level domains – being a required element of every domain name – is irrelevant when assessing whether or not a mark is identical or confusingly similar.

In the light of the above, the Panel finds that the disputed domain name is confusingly similar to Complainant’s trademark LEGO.

B. Rights or Legitimate Interests

According to paragraph 4(a)(ii) of the Policy, the Complainant must prove that the Respondent has no rights or legitimate interests in the domain name.

The following are examples of circumstances where Respondent may have rights or legitimate interests in a disputed domain name (paragraph 4(c) of the Policy):

(i) before any notice to you of the dispute, your use of, or demonstrable preparations to use, the domain name or a name corresponding to the domain name in connection with a bona fide offering of goods or services; or

(ii) you (as an individual, business, or other organization) have been commonly known by the domain name, even if you have acquired no trademark or service mark rights; or

(iii) you are making a legitimate noncommercial or fair use of the domain name, without intent for commercial gain to misleadingly divert consumers or to tarnish the trademark or service mark at issue.

It is the Complainant’s burden to prove that the Respondent lacks rights or a legitimate interest (Document Technologies, Inc. v. International Electronic Communications, Inc., WIPO Case No. D2000-0270). Because it is difficult to produce evidence to support a negative statement, the threshold for the Complainant to prove a lack of legitimate interest is low. Once the Complainant makes out a prima facie showing on this element, the burden of production shifts to the Respondent, although the burden of proof always remains on the Complainant (Do The Hustle, LLC v.Tropic Web, WIPO Case No. D2000-0624; Croatia Airlines d.d. v. Modern Empire Internet Ltd., WIPO Case No. D2003-0455). See also the WIPO Overview of WIPO Panel Views on Selected UDRP Questions, Second Edition (“WIPO Overview 2.0”), paragraph 2.1.).

Here, the Complainant has made a prima facie showing that Respondent lacks any rights to or a legitimate interest in the disputed domain name. In particular, the Complainant has not authorized, licensed, or permitted the Respondent to register or use the disputed domain name or to use the trademark LEGO.

The Complainant has prior rights in the trademark LEGO which precede the Respondent’s registration of the disputed domain name. There has been no evidence adduced to show that the Respondent has been commonly known by the disputed domain name. There has been no evidence adduced to show that the Respondent is using the disputed domain name with a bona fide offering of goods and services. The Respondent is using its disputed domain name to attract Internet users to websites offering Complainant’s products (Donald J. Trump v. Mediaking LLC d/b/a Mediaking Corporation and Aaftek Domain Corp., WIPO Case No. D2010-1404, see also the WIPO Overview 2.0, paragraph 2.6.).

Accordingly, the Panel concludes that the Respondent has no rights or legitimate interests, within the meaning of paragraph 4(a)(ii) and (c)(i) to (iii) of the Policy in respect of the disputed domain name.

C. Registered and Used in Bad Faith

Even if the Respondent has not responded to the Complaint, as is the case here, the Complainant has to prove under the Policy that the Respondent has registered and is using the domain name in bad faith.

Paragraph 4(a)(iii) of the Policy requires the Complainant to prove that the Respondent registered and used the disputed domain name in bad faith. The language of paragraph 4(a)(iii) of the Policy requires that both bad faith registration and bad faith use be established.

Pursuant to paragraph 4(b) of the Policy, the following conduct amounts to registration and use in bad faith on the part of the Respondent:

(i) circumstances indicating that the registrant has registered or the registrant has acquired the domain name primarily for the purpose of selling, renting, or otherwise transferring the domain name registration to the complainant who is the owner of the trademark or service mark or to a competitor of that complainant, for valuable consideration in excess of the registrant’s documented out-of-pocket costs directly related to the domain name; or

(ii) the registrant has registered the domain name in order to prevent the owner of the trademark or service mark from reflecting the mark in a corresponding domain name, provided that the registrant has engaged in a pattern of such conduct; or

(iii) the registrant has registered the domain name primarily for the purpose of disrupting the business of a competitor; or

(iv) by using the domain name, the registrant has intentionally attempted to attract, for commercial gain, Internet users to the registrant’s website or other online location, by creating a likelihood of confusion with the complainant’s mark as to the source, sponsorship, affiliation, or endorsement of the registrant’s website or location or of a product or service on the registrant’s website or location.

As to registration in bad faith, the Complainant has asserted that given the well-known nature and reputation of its trademark LEGO, it is not possible to conceive that the Respondent would have been unaware of this fact at the time of registration. In the Panel’s opinion, in light of Complainant’s numerous trademark registrations and the fact that LEGO is a well-known trademark it cannot reasonably be argued that the Respondent could have been unaware of the trademark rights vested therein when registering the disputed domain name (Inter-IKEA Systems B.V. v. McLaughlin Mobility, WIPO Case No. 2000-0499).

As to use in bad faith, at the date of this decision, the disputed domain name is being used to redirect to other websites offering Complainant’s goods. The Panel considers such use falls within the concept of “passive holding”. It has been established in many UDRP cases that passive holding does not as such prevent a finding of bad faith. Indeed the apparent lack of active use under the appropriate circumstances falls within the concept of the domain name being used in bad faith (Telstra Corporation Limited v. Nuclear Marshmallows, WIPO Case No. D2000-0003; Action S.A. v. Robert Gozdowski, WIPO Case No. D2008-0028). See also the WIPO Overview 2.0, paragraph 3.2.

The Panel finds that the public is likely to be confused into thinking that the disputed domain name has a connection with the Complainant. There is a strong likelihood of confusion as to source, sponsorship, affiliation or endorsement of the website to which the disputed domain name is resolved. Noting also that no clarification as to Respondent’s relationship to Complainant is made on the homepage of the Respondent’s website.

Further, the Panel is of the view that the Respondent’s refusal to voluntarily transfer the disputed domain name and to not respond to a cease and desist letter, or a similar attempt at contact, is relevant in a finding of bad faith (Nike, Inc. v. Azumano Travel, WIPO Case No. D2000-1598).

Although not decisive, the Panel also puts weight on the fact that the Respondent has not honored the Panel with a response and thus provided no evidence of any actual or contemplated good faith use of the disputed domain name.

Thus the Panel concludes, under the totality of the circumstances, that the Respondent has registered and used in bad faith the disputed domain name.

7. Decision

For the foregoing reasons, in accordance with paragraphs 4(i) of the Policy and 15 of the Rules, the Panel orders that the disputed domain name <legodcuniverse.com> be transferred to the Complainant.

Ana María Pacón

Sole Panelist

Date: July 23, 2013

More cases by this complainant

Open this decision on Rightsy