Rightsy — Protect your rights: IP search and flat-fee legal services

Search trademarks

Hachette Filipacchi Presse v. Shi Cheng

WIPO Case No. D2005-1240

Outcome
Transfer
Domain names
elleilove.com
Complainant
Hachette Filipacchi Presse
Respondent
Shi Cheng (China)
Panelist
Richard Tan
Registrar
HiChina Web Solutions (Hong Kong) Limited
Decided
24 Feb 2006
Response
The respondent did not reply
Language
English

Source: WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Center. Official copy: https://www.wipo.int/amc/en/domains/decisions/html/2005/d2005-1240.html

WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Center

ADMINISTRATIVE PANEL DECISION

Hachette Filipacchi Presse v. Shi Cheng

Case No. D2005-1240

1. The Parties

The Complainant is Hachette Filipacchi Presse, Levallois-Perret, France, represented

by Markplus International, France.

The Respondent is Shi Cheng, Beijing, China.

2. The Domain Name and Registrar

The disputed domain name <elleilove.com> is registered with HiChina Web

Solutions (Hong Kong) Limited.

3. Procedural History

The Complaint was filed with the WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Center (the

¡°Center¡±) on December 1, 2005. On December 2, 2005, the Center transmitted by

email to HiChina Web Solutions (Hong Kong) Limited a request for registrar verification

in connection with the domain name at issue.

On December 9, 2005, HiChina Web Solutions (Hong Kong) Limited transmitted

by email to the Center its verification response confirming that the Respondent

is listed as the registrant and providing the contact details for the administrative,

billing, and technical contact and that the registration agreement is in Chinese.

On the same day, the Center notified the Complainant of this, and the Center

requested the Complainant to provide satisfactory evidence of an agreement between

the Complainant and the Respondent to the effect that the proceedings should

be in English, failing which the Complainant had to submit a Chinese translation

of the Complaint.

In the meantime, however, on December 7, 2005, the Respondent had responded,

in English, to the Center¡¯s notification of the Complaint by informing the Center

that their web site showcased their products and that they were authorized to

sell the products in China.

On December 12, 2005, the Complainant wrote to the Center, copying the Respondent,

requesting that the language of the proceedings be in the English language relying

on the following reasons:

1) the disputed domain name contained the English words ¡®I LOVE¡¯;

2) the Respondent responded to the Center¡¯s acknowledgement of receipt of the

Complaint in English; and

3) the difficulty involved obtaining a Chinese translation of the Complaint.

On December 14, 2005, given the circumstances of the case, the Center decided

to allow the commencement of the proceedings without requiring that the Complaint

be filed in Chinese. The Center notified the parties that the Response could

be filed either in English or Chinese, and it would appoint a Panel familiar

with both languages. These directions were without prejudice to the Panel to

decide upon the correct language of the proceedings and to issue directions

in connection therewith. The Center also sent the Respondent, in Chinese, the

Complaint Transmittal Cover Sheet, setting out the procedures to be complied

with in these Proceedings. The Respondent chose not to file a Response.

The Center verified that the Complaint satisfied the formal requirements of

the Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (the ¡°Policy¡±), the Rules

for Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (the ¡°Rules¡±), and the WIPO

Supplemental Rules for Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (the ¡°Supplemental

Rules¡±).

In accordance with the Rules, paragraphs 2(a) and 4(a), the Center formally

notified the Respondent of the Complaint, and the proceedings commenced on December

15, 2005. In accordance with the Rules, paragraph 5(a), the due date for Response

was January 4, 2006. The Respondent did not submit any response. Accordingly,

the Center notified the Respondent¡¯s default on January 11, 2006.

The Center appointed Richard Tan as the sole panelist in this matter on January

25, 2006. The Panel finds that it was properly constituted. The Panel has submitted

the Statement of Acceptance and Declaration of Impartiality and Independence,

as required by the Center to ensure compliance with the Rules, paragraph 7.

Having considered the circumstances of the case, including the fact that (1)

the Complaint was first filed in English, (2) the Respondent previously communicated

with the Center in English, and (3) the Respondent has not filed a Response,

this Panel exercised its discretion pursuant to Paragraph 11(a) of the Rules

to decide that the language of this administrative proceeding would be English.

The Panel issued Administrative Order No. 1 on February 6, 2006, to inform

the parties of this, and also directed therein that the Respondent be at liberty

to file, in English, its Response to the Complaint, if it so desired, within

seven days of the date of the Order, ie, by February 13, 2006. On February 15,

2006, the Center informed the Panel that the Respondent had not filed a response

to the Administrative Order.

4. Factual Background

The Complainant is a French publishing company, publishing several magazines

including the ladies¡¯ fashion magazine, ¡°ELLE¡±.

The Complainant has also secured numerous trade mark registrations for the

mark ¡°ELLE¡± in various jurisdictions around the world, both as a word mark,

and as a stylized version, in various classes, such as Classes 3, 16, 38, 41

and 42. The earliest of these registrations dates back to January 21, 1966.

In the People¡¯s Republic of China, where the Respondent is located, the Complainant

has subsisting registrations for the mark ¡°ELLE¡± in Classes 38 and 41, which

have been in force since 1996.

The Respondent registered the disputed domain name <elleilove.com> with

HiChina Web Solutions (Hong Kong) Limited on August 24, 2005. The disputed domain

name resolves to an advertising portal prominently displaying the words ¡°ELLEilove¡±

and the same stylized version of ¡°ELLE¡± as used by the Complainant in its magazines.

At the top of the home page is a reference to ¡°·¨¹ú°®ÁË ±ÜÔпںìFRANCE ELLE BRAND ADMINISTER

GROUP (HK) LTD¡±. The Chinese text means ¡°French ¡®AI LE¡¯ [a Chinese phonetic

equivalent of ¡°ELLE¡±] contraceptive lipstick¡±.

5. Parties¡¯ Contentions

A. Complainant

The Complainant contends as follows:

(a) that the disputed domain name <elleilove.com> is confusingly similar

to the Complainant¡¯s ¡°ELLE¡± mark in that it incorporates Complainant¡¯s mark

in its entirety combined with the words ¡°i¡± and ¡°love¡±, and that this is insufficient

to distinguish the disputed domain name from Complainant¡¯s mark, because the

predominant part of the disputed domain name is ¡°ELLE¡±.

(b) the Respondent has no rights or legitimate interest in respect of the disputed

domain name.

(c) the Respondent¡¯s registration and use of the disputed domain name is in

bad faith as by registering the disputed domain name with knowledge of the Complainant¡¯s

rights in its ELLE mark, it sought to use the disputed domain name to intentionally

attract, for commercial gain, Internet users by creating a likelihood of confusion

with the Complainant¡¯s ELLE mark as to the source, sponsorship, affiliation

and/or endorsement of the Respondent¡¯s website which promotes merchandise, albeit

not related to the Complainant.

B. Respondent

The Respondent has not filed any Response.

6. Discussion and Findings

The Complainant has the burden of proving each of the following three elements

under paragraph 4(a) of the Policy in order to be entitled to a transfer of

the disputed domain name:

(i) that the Respondent¡¯s domain name is identical or confusingly similar to

a trademark or service mark in which the Complainant has rights; and

(ii) that the Respondent has no rights or legitimate interests in respect of

the domain name; and

(iii) that the Respondent domain name has been registered and is being used

in bad faith¡±.

The Respondent is required under the Rules to submit a Response to the Complaint

within twenty days of the date of commencement of the administrative proceedings.

In the event of a failure to submit a Response, paragraph 5(e) of the Rules

provides that absent any exceptional circumstances, the Panel is to decide the

dispute ¡°based upon the complaint.¡± Paragraph 14(b) of the Rules further provides

that if a party, in the absence of exceptional circumstances, fails to comply

with any provision of the Rules, the Panel is entitled to ¡°draw such inferences¡±

from the Respondent¡¯s failure to comply with the Rules ¡°as it considers appropriate.¡±

As the Respondent has not submitted a Response, and there having been no exceptional

circumstances brought to the attention of the Panel, in accordance with paragraph

5(e) of the Rules, this Panel is entitled to decide the dispute based on the

Complaint and to accept as true the factual averments of the Complaint for the

purposes of these proceedings. Talk City, Inc. v. Michael Robertson, WIPO

Case No. D2000-0009.

The Respondent¡¯s default, however, does not lead to an automatic ruling in

favor of the Complainant. The burden remains on the Complainant to establish,

on a balance of probabilities, that it is entitled to a transfer of the domain

name. World Wrestling Federation Entertainment, Inc. v. Michael Bosman, WIPO

Case No. D1999-0001.

A. Identical or Confusingly Similar Domain Name

The Complainant is required under paragraph 4(a)(i) of the Policy to prove

that the domain name is identical or confusingly similar to a trademark in which

the Complainant has rights.

The Complainant has furnished prima facie evidence that it is the owner of

a number of trade marks in respect of the mark ¡°ELLE¡±, and accordingly, has

rights in the same. This mark has also been registered in Classes 38 and 41

in the People¡¯s Republic of China, where the Respondent is located, since 1996.

The Complainant has also sought to argue that the Complainant¡¯s mark is well

known.

On the basis of its trade mark registrations, this Panel accepts that the Complainant

has rights in the mark ¡°ELLE¡±.

The disputed domain name incorporates the Complainant¡¯s mark in its entirety,

and combines it with the generic words ¡®i¡¯ and ¡®love¡¯. It is well-established

under the Policy that a domain name composed of a trademark coupled with a generic

term can still be regarded as confusingly similar to the trademark, see for

example, Experian Information Solutions, Inc. v. BPB Prumerica Travel (a/k/a

SFXB a/k/a H. Bousquet a/k/a Brian Evans) WIPO

Case No. D2002-0367, where the panel held that the addition of the generic

term, ¡®automotive¡¯ did not distinguish a respondent¡¯s domain name <experianautomotive.com>

from the complainant¡¯s mark, as the domain name contained the Complainant¡¯s

EXPERIAN mark in its entirety.

This Panel would similarly find that the addition of the words ¡°ilove¡± to the

Complainant¡¯s ¡°ELLE¡± mark is not sufficient to distinguish it from the Complainant¡¯s

mark, and that the subject domain name is confusingly similar therewith.

B. Rights or Legitimate Interests

The Complainant is also required under paragraph 4(a)(ii) of the Policy to

prove that the Respondent has no rights or legitimate interests in the disputed

domain name. The onus is initially on the Complainant to establish a prima facie

case, and once this has been done, the onus shifts to the Respondent to prove

the contrary. See Lucasfilm Ltd. and Lucas Licensing Ltd. v. Cupcake City and

John Zuccarini, WIPO Case No. D2001-0700.

It has also been recognized by many panels that it is difficult for the Complainant

to prove a negative for the purposes of paragraph 4(a)(ii) of the Policy, since

it raises matters within the knowledge of the Respondent. Accordingly, many

panels have held that it is sufficient that the complainant show a prima facie

evidence in order to shift the burden of proof on the respondent (see, for example,

Anti Flirt S.A. and Mr. Jacques Amsellem v. WCVC, WIPO

Case No. D2000-1553, Intocast AG v. Lee Daeyoon, WIPO

Case No. D2000-1467).

In the present case, the Complainant asserts that the Respondent has no rights

or legitimate interests in respect of the disputed domain name, and that the

Respondent refers directly to the Complainant¡¯s ¡°ELLE¡± magazine in its website,

and this use was without the consent of the Complainant as the mark owner. The

Complainant also asserts that the Respondent does not own any trade mark rights

in the disputed domain name and has no links with the Complainant.

Even in the absence of a Response, this Panel remains obliged to consider whether

any of the (non-exhaustive) circumstances provided in paragraph 4(c) of the

Policy are present to support a finding of the Respondent having rights or legitimate

interests in respect of the disputed domain name, namely:

(i) before any notice to the Respondent of the dispute, the Respondent¡¯s use

of, or demonstrable preparations to use, the domain name or a name corresponding

to the domain name in connection with a bona fide offering of goods or services;

or

(ii) the Respondent (as an individual, business, or other organization) has

been commonly known by the domain name, even if it has acquired no trademark

or service mark rights; or

(iii) the Respondent is making a legitimate noncommercial or fair use of the

domain name, without intent for commercial gain to misleadingly divert consumers

or to tarnish the trademark or service mark at issue.

If any of the above circumstances is established, the Respondent may be said

to have rights to or legitimate interests in the domain name for the purposes

of paragraph 4(a)(ii) (see Digital Vision, Ltd. v. Advanced Chemill Systems,

WIPO Case No. D2001-0827), in which event, the Complaint must be denied.

To establish that the Respondent has rights or legitimate interests in the

disputed domain name under Paragraph 4(c)(i) the critical requirement is the

Respondent¡¯s use of the domain name in connection with a bona fide offering

of goods or services.

It appears to the Panel that the Respondent¡¯s website provides feminine interest

news items and health products. However, there are very extensive references

to the mark ¡°ELLE¡± and also in the same typeface as that used by the Complainant.

The site is also peppered with references to ¡°International Brand¡± and ¡°France

Science¡±.

Since the Respondent has not filed a Response, the Panel would also infer that

the Respondent has no trademarks or service marks identical to ¡°ELLE¡± (See Nat¡¯l

Academy of Recording Arts & Sciences Inc. v. Lsites, National Arbitration

Forum, Case No. FA00103059). There is also no evidence to suggest that the Respondent

has been commonly known by the domain name.

The overall impression created is that the Respondent is aware of the Complainant¡¯s

mark, but yet has sought to use this mark in connection with the offering of

its own products for commercial sale at its website under the disputed domain

name.

The Panel accordingly concludes that the Respondent has not used the disputed

domain name in connection with a bona fide offering of goods or services, and

that the Respondent has used the same to misleadingly divert consumers within

the meaning of paragraph 4(c)(iii) of the Policy.

This Panel accordingly finds that the Respondent has no rights or legitimate

interests in the disputed domain name within the meaning of Paragraph 4(a)(ii)

of the Policy.

C. Registered and Used in Bad Faith

Paragraph 4(a)(iii) of the Policy provides that the Complainant must, in addition

to the matters set out above, further demonstrate that the disputed domain name

has been registered and used in bad faith.

Paragraph 4(b) of the Policy provides a non-exhaustive list of circumstances

which ¡°if found by the Panel to be present, shall be evidence of the registration

and use of a domain name in bad faith¡±, namely:

(i) circumstances indicating that the Respondent has registered or has acquired

the domain name primarily for the purpose of selling, renting, or otherwise

transferring the domain name registration to the complainant who is the owner

of the trademark or service mark or to a competitor of that complainant, for

valuable consideration in excess of your documented out-of-pocket costs directly

related to the domain name; or

(ii) the Respondent has registered the domain name in order to prevent the

owner of the trademark or service mark from reflecting the mark in a corresponding

domain name, provided that you have engaged in a pattern of such conduct; or

(iii) you have registered the domain name primarily for the purpose of disrupting

the business of a competitor; or

(iv) by using the domain name, you have intentionally attempted to attract,

for commercial gain, Internet users to your web site or other on-line location,

by creating a likelihood of confusion with the complainant¡¯s mark as to the

source, sponsorship, affiliation, or endorsement of your web site or location

or of a product or service on your web site or location¡±

The Complainant asserts that the disputed domain name is registered and used

by the Respondent in order to attract Internet users to the Respondent¡¯s site,

by exploiting the Complainant¡¯s mark and the goodwill attached to them, and

that this fulfills the requirement under Paragraph 4(a)(iii) of the Policy.

In the absence of a response, having regard to the Respondent¡¯s website and

all the circumstances, and in particular, the extensive references to the Complainant¡¯s

¡°ELLE¡± mark on the Respondent¡¯s website, which are also in the same stylized

form as that used by the Complainant, the Panel is prepared to infer that the

Respondent had registered and used the disputed domain name in bad faith with

knowledge of the Complainant¡¯s rights in its ¡°ELLE¡± mark, and to intentionally

attract, for commercial gain, Internet users by creating a likelihood of confusion

with the Complainant¡¯s ELLE mark as to the source, sponsorship, affiliation

and/or endorsement of the Respondent¡¯s website promoting merchandise unrelated

to the Complainant within the meaning of paragraph 4(b)(iv) of the Policy.

The Panel accordingly finds paragraph 4(a)(iii) of the Policy has been established.

7. Decision

For all the foregoing reasons, in accordance with paragraphs 4(i) of the Policy

and 15 of the Rules, the Panel orders that the domain name <elleilove.com

> be transferred to the Complainant.

Richard Tan

Sole Panelist

Date: February 24, 2006

More cases by this complainant

Open this decision on Rightsy